Since the dawn of American democracy, a free press has been cited as essential to its function and survival. What does it actually mean for the press to play an essential role? To serve American democracy? Is the press doing that today?
Tom Rosenstiel, author of The Next Journalism, argues that the press must change in order to fulfill that responsibility. It starts with understanding what the people actually need and how to provide real tools for life in the United States.
Transcript
Hannah McCarthy: [00:00:00] I grew up in a house, Nick, where some chair in the kitchen was always stacked high with the Boston Globe. My parents read that paper cover to cover, [00:00:10] except the sports section.
Nick Capodice: [00:00:12] You McCarthys are many things, and sports aren't it?
Hannah McCarthy: [00:00:16] We knew our lane and we stuck to it. Anyway, in my [00:00:20] house there was this unspoken understanding that without a newspaper, we were missing a part of our world. It [00:00:30] was this absolutely essential tool. If the paper was late, if you couldn't read it before work or school, that was basically worse than running out of milk before breakfast. [00:00:40]
Nick Capodice: [00:00:40] I have seen your mom when the paper is late, and that is a letter to the publisher level problem.
Hannah McCarthy: [00:00:47] Also, full disclosure my mom used to work in classified advertising at the [00:00:50] globe, so she is particularly invested. And at least when I was a kid, the paper wasn't just a source of what was going on internationally and in the US, or with the federal [00:01:00] or local government. It was here's what's going on in the city this week. Here's the weather. There's a new bookstore. There's a new restaurant. There's a sale at Filene's.
Nick Capodice: [00:01:09] For [00:01:10] those born after 1998. That was a department store.
Hannah McCarthy: [00:01:14] Rip Filene's basement in particular. But, Nick, all of that stuff that informs your everyday [00:01:20] life, from what to do this weekend to what you can buy for cheap. You don't need the paper for that anymore. And all the other [00:01:30] stuff. As in the hard news, it might give you information, but how is it making you feel connected? Supported? Like you've [00:01:40] got some good tools.
Archival: [00:01:41] In our 24 hour news cycle, Americans are having difficulty avoiding the constant negative headlines.
Archival: [00:01:47] Those who constantly check the latest headlines [00:01:50] end up with significantly greater physical ill being than those who tune in. Less often.
Archival: [00:01:54] The daily din of bad news can feel like an assault, even to the most skilled among us.
Hannah McCarthy: [00:02:03] So [00:02:00] a 2025 Pew Research poll found that Americans are more likely to feel angry, sad, [00:02:10] scared, and confused than they are to feel hopeful, happy, and empowered. From the news. So if it isn't giving us what we want and what [00:02:20] we need, and it's making us feel bad. Is there anything we can do to change that?
Tom Rosenstiel: [00:02:28] Journalism itself has [00:02:30] to become indispensable. Now, what does that mean?
Hannah McCarthy: [00:02:36] This is Tom Rosenstiel. He's a journalist, journalism [00:02:40] professor, author, founder of the project for Excellence in Journalism. I could go on. He has plenty of recommendations for journalists everywhere. But when [00:02:50] I called him, I wanted to start with the civics 101 of it all. Because at the core of everything we've been talking about is this principle that a lot of [00:03:00] people agree on. You know, democracy and the free press are intertwined. They are necessary, one for the other. And as much as we [00:03:10] say it, I'm not sure that we entirely understand what that means or have very many conversations about what it actually means for the free press and democracy to go hand in hand. So that's [00:03:20] where I would love to start. What does that actually mean? A free press being essential to democracy and vice versa.
Tom Rosenstiel: [00:03:27] Think of it sort of as the origin story. [00:03:30] Before there was journalism, before there was there were people trying to write about what was going on inside Parliament [00:03:40] or other civic institutions. The knowledge about those things were held by only a few. It was essentially privileged and private [00:03:50] knowledge. And as journalism emerged at the beginning of the of the 17th 19th century. Those things that were only [00:04:00] known by a few began to be known by the many, by people.
Nick Capodice: [00:04:04] I've never really considered how radical that must have been for the people who are not in power [00:04:10] to suddenly know what the people in power are doing and saying.
Tom Rosenstiel: [00:04:15] Even the term public opinion began to emerge as an artifact, [00:04:20] a product of journalism, and in England, newspapers had to sue to have the right to publish [00:04:30] the discussions that occurred inside the British Parliament, because these people didn't want anybody to know what they were saying.
Nick Capodice: [00:04:37] So that public opinion thing, isn't there a Thomas [00:04:40] Jefferson quote about that, about how that's connected to the press?
Hannah McCarthy: [00:04:43] There sure is. Jefferson said that the basis of our government, as in American democracy, is [00:04:50] the opinion of the people, which he thought was informed by newspapers. How are people supposed to form an opinion about their government if they don't know what [00:05:00] is going on inside their government?
Nick Capodice: [00:05:02] Yeah, and it's right there in the very First Amendment. Congress cannot abridge the freedom of speech or of the press. [00:05:10]
Tom Rosenstiel: [00:05:10] And democracy can't happen. Or, you know, people can't vote. People can't have a public opinion about public matters if they don't have information, if [00:05:20] they don't know what the facts are, if they don't know what the bills are that are being considered and what they might do and things like that. Now, [00:05:30] that doesn't mean that journalism gets it right, or that we live up to that obligation and that responsibility, but that's why it exists, and that's why journalism [00:05:40] is democratizing. It can also be diverting. It could be a waste of time. It could be inaccurate. It could be a lot of bad things.
Hannah McCarthy: [00:05:50] This [00:05:50] is Civics 101. I'm Hannah McCarthy.
Nick Capodice: [00:05:53] I'm Nick Capodice.
Hannah McCarthy: [00:05:54] And these days, surveys don't just show us that the news makes us feel bad. The data also shows [00:06:00] us that fewer people are reading and tuning into the news. They show us that public trust in the media has declined a lot. So if a free press [00:06:10] really is vital to democracy and the press isn't doing so hot, does something need to change?
Archival: [00:06:20] Extra [00:06:20] extra extra extra. Read all about it. Me and Playboy in trouble again.
Nick Capodice: [00:06:46] We're [00:06:40] back. We are talking about democracy, the people, the [00:06:50] press, and whether journalism is playing the role it should be playing in that relationship.
Hannah McCarthy: [00:06:55] And we are talking with Tom Rosenstiel, the author of The Next Journalism How [00:07:00] the Press Must Change to Serve Democracy. And Tom has a lot to say about what it takes for the free press to be at its best. What [00:07:10] have you identified over the course of your career as the obstacles to that?
Tom Rosenstiel: [00:07:16] Well, one obstacle that we're facing right now is [00:07:20] declining audience. But I think by and large, journalists have misunderstood why we're losing our audience.
Hannah McCarthy: [00:07:28] So, Nick, data from the Pew Research [00:07:30] Center tells us that overall daily newspaper circulation and digital subscriptions have been in decline for a decade. Tv news and terrestrial [00:07:40] radio audiences have been dropping since 2016, according to a 2026 report from Northwestern University. The U.S. has lost over 3400 [00:07:50] local papers since 2005. And there are a lot of reasons for this. But Nick, I am wondering, what do you think happened [00:08:00] to the news?
Nick Capodice: [00:08:02] Wow. Um, if I have to give you an answer, Hannah and I know we can't keep blaming the internet, but I would say because [00:08:10] the internet.
Hannah McCarthy: [00:08:11] You and Childish Gambino both.
Tom Rosenstiel: [00:08:13] We think that, oh, everybody's going to the internet, you know, and, uh, getting information in snippets. Actually, [00:08:20] the problem is more conceptual than that. The problem that we have, we're delivering a flawed product, a product that's failed in the marketplace. Now, [00:08:30] why has it failed? A lot of what made journalism products like the newspaper or a TV news show indispensable [00:08:40] for people in the 20th century were things that surrounded it. You could not buy a house or sell a bike, or [00:08:50] rent an apartment, or know what was on television or what was at the movies, or get a coupon for the grocery store without the things that came in the newspaper, [00:09:00] without those classified ads and grocery coupons. People now get all of that elsewhere.
Hannah McCarthy: [00:09:06] We've talked about the fact that you don't need a newspaper to tell you what's on sale at [00:09:10] Filene's anymore.
Nick Capodice: [00:09:11] And it aged us both.
Hannah McCarthy: [00:09:12] But you also don't need a newspaper for classified ads. I mentioned that my mom used to work in class ads at the globe. Those were [00:09:20] the pages where businesses or just individual people would list like bicycle for sale, apartment for rent. Now hiring for this job, a 28 year old [00:09:30] seeking life partner.
Nick Capodice: [00:09:31] All stuff you can get on Craigslist, Facebook Marketplace, dating apps, etc..
Hannah McCarthy: [00:09:36] Exactly. So if news outlets aren't providing that service [00:09:40] to the community anymore, that essential stuff for day to day life, Tom says journalists need to pivot to make the journalism itself [00:09:50] indispensable to day to day life.
Tom Rosenstiel: [00:09:53] The first step in that is for us to think about how is this particular story actually going to help people? [00:10:00] What need is it serving? And we didn't really have to think about that back in the day in the 20th century, because there was all these useful things that were part [00:10:10] of the newspaper. And so most journalists said, well, okay, while they're getting that stuff, I'm going to tell them a bunch of things that I think they should know that are important to their lives. [00:10:20] I'm going to expose them to that.
Nick Capodice: [00:10:22] That is a business model, isn't it? Come on down for pie and balloons for the kids. And while I have your attention, ladies and gentlemen, I've got something [00:10:30] I think you need to know.
Tom Rosenstiel: [00:10:31] The academic literature is really clear on this. We got people's attention by telling them things that were wrong and things that were weird. You [00:10:40] know, man bites dog is weird. The airplane that crashes is something wrong. The airplane that lands is, you know, is okay. So we don't write stories about [00:10:50] the airplane that lands only about the airplane that crashes.
Nick Capodice: [00:10:57] But the airplane that lands. That's [00:11:00] not news, Hannah. You know, I understand he's using a metaphor, but who's going to read or listen to a totally expected and normal thing happened [00:11:10] today? Everybody. Nothing wrong here. No one's going to listen to that. Okay?
Hannah McCarthy: [00:11:14] Sure. But at the same time that hyper focus on the things that are wrong and the things that are weird [00:11:20] is the reason why so many of us end up in a doom scroll. Like, what good is that doing us? I think a lot of people are familiar with [00:11:30] the experience of reading or listening to, or watching the news, and then feeling a lot worse afterwards. There's plenty of poison out there. Not [00:11:40] a lot of antidote.
Tom Rosenstiel: [00:11:41] Another person that I talked to said the primary ethos of journalism is everything is a mess. Good luck to you.
Hannah McCarthy: [00:11:52] What [00:11:50] is the point of news that we can't do anything about or do anything with? Plane crashes. [00:12:00] Well, that's sad and scary. Kind of makes me want to stay home. But a story about how air traffic control actually works. And, you know, ten things you'll see on the [00:12:10] tarmac that are keeping you safe. Now I have information with a purpose. I feel better at the airport, less confused when you know my plane is [00:12:20] taxiing for 40 minutes. I might be more patient, more empathetic to the people who do the job. I might care more about, you know, who in Congress wants [00:12:30] to privatize air traffic control and how air traffic controllers feel about that.
Nick Capodice: [00:12:36] And the result is you're less anxious on a plane, and you have a new [00:12:40] piece of information for the next time you vote for your congressperson.
Hannah McCarthy: [00:12:43] Sure. Yeah, exactly. And, you know, this story doesn't get my attention because something is weird or wrong. [00:12:50] It gets my attention because there is something in there that I find useful. Tom has found news outlets that are trying this tactic, focusing on [00:13:00] something called user needs, or the job to be done when it comes to the kinds of stories they're telling.
Tom Rosenstiel: [00:13:06] The concept of the job to be done goes [00:13:10] to this question of is it what I think is important, or is it what the audience thinks is important? The guy who developed this, uh, concept was a [00:13:20] disruption theorist at Harvard Business School named Clayton Christensen, and he realized that the job to be done is often not what the producer of the product [00:13:30] thinks it is.
Hannah McCarthy: [00:13:31] Tom says that once a newsroom starts thinking about what people actually need, what they will actually use, more people might turn [00:13:40] to that newsroom for exactly that. Like he talked about this one particular arm of the BBC, which started identifying user needs stuff readers [00:13:50] and listeners could actually use. They made labels. One was update me.
Nick Capodice: [00:13:56] Well, that just sounds like the news to me. Like hard news.
Hannah McCarthy: [00:13:59] These are [00:14:00] more like threads of notifications and they're really common. The president plans to meet a world leader. And then the update is the president is meeting with [00:14:10] the world leader.
Nick Capodice: [00:14:11] And then it's like, here's what the president said to the world leader, right?
Hannah McCarthy: [00:14:14] And then here is what the world leader said after the meeting. There are developments adding [00:14:20] layers of information as more stuff happens. So when the BBC started labeling their stories.
Tom Rosenstiel: [00:14:27] At the beginning, they noticed that 70% [00:14:30] of the stories that that language service the BBC was doing were simply update stories. This happened. Or here's an update on some ongoing story, which [00:14:40] is most of what we traditionally do in journalism.
Hannah McCarthy: [00:14:43] But again, the idea here was to figure out what BBC readers and listeners actually needed, the [00:14:50] kinds of stories people would turn to them for. So Update Me is one of the labels in most of their stories. Got that? But there were other kinds, like Connect Me stories [00:15:00] that helped people get involved, keep me engaged, stories about the stuff people are talking about right now, and how you can be a part of that conversation. Even [00:15:10] divert me stories that were just funny or entertaining. And once the BBC labeled their stories and paid attention to the stuff people were [00:15:20] reading and listening to, it turned out that the connection and engagement and entertainment stories were way more popular. Update stories, [00:15:30] aka most of their stories, not so much. So they pivoted. And that meant publishing less stuff, but more [00:15:40] of the stuff people actually wanted and their audience tripled.
Tom Rosenstiel: [00:15:46] Now, how is it you could do fewer pieces and triple [00:15:50] your audience? It's because you're doing more stories that took more time, that were more useful, more valuable. They weren't these ephemeral. This just happened stories which tend [00:16:00] to get very low engagement.
Hannah McCarthy: [00:16:04] Nick, I think a lot about this time I was preparing to vote in my hometown years ago. And, [00:16:10] you know, at that time, I could have told you about dozens of national issues and how they were developing, like what this federal candidate or that executive branch official had done that week. The latest development [00:16:20] in some international standoff, etc.. But I could not, for the life of me find substantial information about the local candidates I was supposed to be voting [00:16:30] for. My point is, my brain was full of all of this national and international stuff, and I could get all of the updates on that. But what I needed and what I wanted, [00:16:40] that was hard to come by. Mumbai.
Nick Capodice: [00:16:43] You wanted the lowercase d democracy stuff.
Hannah McCarthy: [00:16:46] Little lowercase d, the democracy closest to me. The one I had a [00:16:50] real chance of affecting with my vote, my participation, my opinions, my ideas. Instead, I had this. Who are you people and what do you want? [00:17:00] Feeling. Also, I was a journalist at that point and I was feeling, oh no, am I a part of my own problem?
Nick Capodice: [00:17:09] Or at the very least, [00:17:10] not a part of your own solution?
Hannah McCarthy: [00:17:12] Oh, yeah. That's good. All [00:17:20] right. Nick, we have talked about stories with a job to be done about the kinds of things it seems like people need. But [00:17:30] the question remains, how can today's journalists get their provide that serve that lowercase d. Democracy. [00:17:40] And I'm going to get to that right after a quick break. We're [00:17:50] back. We're talking with Tom Rosenstiel, author of The Next Journalism. And Nick, we're [00:18:00] trying to figure out why the free press is perhaps not doing what it says it does, being essential to democracy. So we talked about [00:18:10] being of use to people by paying attention to what people actually need. But there's another problem that Tom thinks we're going to need to address if the press is going to better [00:18:20] serve democracy. A lot of people just do not trust the press.
Tom Rosenstiel: [00:18:25] So there's lots of research now about trust, because the numbers have been looking bad for [00:18:30] a couple of decades. And so a bunch of scholars have delved into this, and the answer to declining trust has been, well, let's become more transparent about how we do our work. [00:18:40] And if we show people how we do our work, they'll trust us because they'll see like, we're very competent, we're very experienced. We check our facts and things like that. What the research [00:18:50] shows is that the kind of trust that is required for a news organization is what they call relational trust.
Nick Capodice: [00:18:56] So I have a feeling this is going to mean more than just telling people [00:19:00] they can trust us.
Hannah McCarthy: [00:19:01] Which is another thing that we journalists say all the time. We do trustworthy work, but labeling it as trustworthy is [00:19:10] not the same thing as earning the trust of people.
Tom Rosenstiel: [00:19:14] And that relational trust includes three key things. Only two of which I think journalists [00:19:20] really think about. One is are you competent? And that we think we're really good at that. And if we could just explain why, how we do what we do, people should [00:19:30] trust us. Another is are we accountable? In other words, if we screw up, will we admit it? There were grudgingly coming along, but we don't like [00:19:40] big corrections and things like that. But the third one is one that most journalists do not even think about. And that is benevolence, which really means what is your [00:19:50] motive? Can I trust that you're in it for the right reasons? And when you dive into the distrust or the trust numbers, it's that question of [00:20:00] what do I think your motive is, which is the real source of what people think. We write stories to sell newspapers. You know, to get clicks [00:20:10] that we are secretly working for the Democratic Party or that we if you're on the left, that you are a voice of the establishment and probably [00:20:20] a white middle aged male establishment. There's a lot of inferring that goes on into motive. Now, what can we do about that [00:20:30] is a challenging thing.
Nick Capodice: [00:20:34] You know, Hannah, if someone rarely admits they're wrong and spends their days talking about [00:20:40] what is wrong with other people and the rest of the world. I gotta say that for me, that does not inspire confidence.
Hannah McCarthy: [00:20:46] Same here. Easy to see that speck of sawdust in someone else's [00:20:50] eye. Not so much the plank in your own. When Tom talks about suspicions about journalists, this lack of trust, he explained that there is a disconnect between what journalists [00:21:00] value and what the public values.
Tom Rosenstiel: [00:21:03] You know, we have these certain values, like people in power, you know, can't be trusted. We have to watch them. [00:21:10] We make society better by spotlighting its problems. The more facts you have, if you have enough facts, you'll have the truth. People with less power in society. We need to raise their voices [00:21:20] up. These are not bad values, but there are limits to them.
Hannah McCarthy: [00:21:25] So the press is the watchdog as the one holding power to account, finding out the bad [00:21:30] stuff that's going on. That seems like it must be supporting democracy, right? You're rooting out corruption, making sure our institutions work. That is [00:21:40] making the world better, isn't it?
Tom Rosenstiel: [00:21:42] So one of the things that breeds suspicions about our motives when we test this is we took [00:21:50] five core values that journalists share, some of which I just articulated and tested. How much support was there for them? The only one [00:22:00] that had majority support was the more facts you have about something, the more likely you are to understand it accurately. Very few people [00:22:10] thought you make society better. You know, like only 20% of people thought you made society better by spotlighting these problems. They're more inclined to think, yes, but yes, [00:22:20] I want to know the problems. But that's not really the only way to make society better. So we think we're just doing our job and that people should understand [00:22:30] this, when in reality, what we think of our job, people are inherently suspicious of the way we want to go about it.
Hannah McCarthy: [00:22:39] To be [00:22:40] clear, Tom is not saying that journalists should stop publishing stories on corruption, should stop holding power to account.
Tom Rosenstiel: [00:22:47] Some people might overreact to the approach [00:22:50] that I'm advocating and say, well, you know, are you saying that we shouldn't do investigative reporting? No.
Hannah McCarthy: [00:22:54] But as Tom puts it, journalists often think they're doing more investigating than they're actually [00:23:00] doing. He is calling for, you know, asking the right questions, asking whether or not someone is doing a good job. And then deeper [00:23:10] than that, trying to understand what a good job would actually mean. When you start to ask those questions, you start to dig deeper. And those are the ways that you might find [00:23:20] that corruption. But along the way, you're able to provide your audience with more meaningful, more useful coverage of those people in power.
Nick Capodice: [00:23:30] All [00:23:30] of this makes sense to me, Hannah, but isn't there another reason people are suspicious of the press because they have been told to be suspicious [00:23:40] of the press.
Hannah McCarthy: [00:23:41] That's part of it. But according to Tom, so is the way a lot of journalists go about their work.
Tom Rosenstiel: [00:23:47] We don't quite get that there's [00:23:50] some skepticism about our motives. So this ideology we have, it's [00:24:00] not really a partizan one, but it has political implications for people. It kind of leans it's a little anti-authoritarian. It's a little, [00:24:10] you know, suspicious. It's a little negative. It didn't used to be such a problem when there were three TV channels, and you had to get all your national news from them. [00:24:20] There was one newspaper in every town, three local TV stations. I didn't have a lot of choice. The decline in trust correlates very, very strongly to people having more choices [00:24:30] and then hearing more stuff from other people, many of which decide that they're going to acquire an audience base by criticizing the mainstream media. [00:24:40] So what can we do? One of the things that I advocate is we [00:24:50] really need to understand the audience better.
Hannah McCarthy: [00:24:52] One thing Tom says journalists can do, and this is how I kind of take it, is remember that you are also [00:25:00] a human being in the world. You also need things.
Tom Rosenstiel: [00:25:04] There are these ways that you can discover the bubble that you've slipped into as a journalist. [00:25:10] One of them is a simple exercise called a dinner table exercise, where you get journalists in a room and you say, okay, you're at a dinner party. Let's say you've got kids. [00:25:20] Just tell stories about your engagement with the school system in the last year. And typically, what happens in this exercise, people say, oh, the busses are constantly [00:25:30] breaking down. Or, you know, I don't understand why the school has to start so early. My kids are asleep when I have to wake them up, you know? Couldn't they start at a normal [00:25:40] time? At a time that's better for them. And then you stop and you say, okay, make a story list. And the story list that comes out of the organic stories that people tell about their, their personal [00:25:50] interaction are drastically different than if you'd said, okay, take a half, half an hour and make a story list.
Nick Capodice: [00:25:57] Hannah. This happens to us a [00:26:00] lot. Like, for example, when you had to register your car in New Hampshire.
Hannah McCarthy: [00:26:04] Oh yeah. You think you have the right documents, you think you are in the right place, but you are wrong.
Nick Capodice: [00:26:09] And [00:26:10] as you were ranting about it, you were like, now this is a Civics 101 episode.
Hannah McCarthy: [00:26:14] Because I am also a person in the world, and I could really use a detailed explanation as to how to [00:26:20] help make my life better when it comes to this situation.
Nick Capodice: [00:26:23] Which reminds me, I need to make a civics 101 episode about navigating health insurance because oh my, [00:26:30] am I trying to navigate that right now.
Tom Rosenstiel: [00:26:33] Okay. Talk about healthcare like, you know, or talk about government, you know. And oh yeah, man. Why don't you get my car registered? And that took forever. Whatever. [00:26:40] So that's one way and, and very easy way. And actually when you do that, it can be very effective to have non-journalists in the group, but also then go talk [00:26:50] to people, you know, publications do events. And those events are a great way to just get with people. And all of this is, I mean, it's not like [00:27:00] journalism is frozen in time, but there was a time when we were fat and happy. I mean, I worked at the LA times, [00:27:10] we made so much money, we didn't know what to do with it. The lunchroom, the Picasso room, because there were Picasso's hanging on the wall.
Hannah McCarthy: [00:27:19] Oh. Get out. [00:27:20]
Tom Rosenstiel: [00:27:20] I'm not kidding. Uh, not the not the pleb lunchroom, but the lunchroom for like, editors and, you know, more seniors and those [00:27:30] days are gone. But in those days, we didn't really want to interact with the great unwashed public that read us. There was an editor in Oregon who said, [00:27:40] the attitude in the newsroom is so derisive towards the public that she instituted a policy where each day a different reporter in the newsroom was going to have to [00:27:50] answer the phone from the public. And she said there were a couple reporters. They thought they were so, so grumpy that they might actually exempt them from this, but [00:28:00] they just wanted people to, like, have some interaction with the public. We've come a long way, but we need to go further. And the reason we need to go further [00:28:10] is the business model now requires it. It's such a shift to think that our economic viability depends on people [00:28:20] paying for the product. That is just it's a tectonic shift in the way that this profession needs to survive.
Nick Capodice: [00:28:32] So, [00:28:30] Hannah, it should be obvious how absurd it is that a newsroom of journalists did not want to speak to the [00:28:40] public. But I think understanding the decline in newspapers and radio and even television news, understanding how we went from Picasso's [00:28:50] on the wall to whatever the opposite of Picasso's On the Wall is, does come down to understanding, like really understanding that [00:29:00] we need to talk to the public.
Hannah McCarthy: [00:29:02] Yeah. And actually, that brings me to the last question that I had for Tom. And you know, this, Nick, it's something that I ask everybody [00:29:10] at the end of an interview because I almost always miss something. Is there anything that we didn't touch on that you would like either journalists [00:29:20] or non-journalists, other members of the public who listen to this podcast to understand about either this book or the way that you are looking at the media landscape [00:29:30] today.
Tom Rosenstiel: [00:29:30] Yeah. Yeah. There is one thing that's important, I think really important. And that is the question of do we have any common facts anymore? Or do we live in our own separate little silos? [00:29:40] Fact silos. The reality is not quite as dire as it seems when you just think about politics. There's [00:29:50] plenty of common facts you know about our sports teams, our kids schools, you know, the roads, the weather. People live in a mixed media environment a lot more than we think they do. [00:30:00] Nobody actually is just getting everything from Fox News or MSNBC. When I say nobody, the vast majority live in a mixed media environment, but [00:30:10] journalists really need to see, uh, as part of their mission to create a public square, to create a place where [00:30:20] we can understand each other, but that we can make people who disagree with each other comprehensible to each other. If on [00:30:30] Election Day or after Election Day, the result is incomprehensible, that's actually a failure of journalism. The problem isn't that the audience doesn't understand [00:30:40] our version of truth. The problem is we don't understand the audience. We need to [00:30:50] make the country. However challenging or or polarized it might be, we need to make the country more understandable to [00:31:00] the people in it. At the moment, a lot of journalism enables polarization because we. It's a way of getting attention. [00:31:10] So like, look at this outrageous thing this guy did. You're actually rewarding that guy by spotlighting his outrage. What I say in the book is instead of thinking [00:31:20] that our job is to alert a passive public to things they should know, we should define our mission as helping people live their lives [00:31:30] and improve their communities.
Hannah McCarthy: [00:31:35] And to that end, Nick, you know how we so often say in the Civics [00:31:40] 101 credits, if you have a question for Civics 101, you can submit that at our website.
Nick Capodice: [00:31:44] I have said that more times than I can count.
Hannah McCarthy: [00:31:46] And how often do you listen to the credits of a podcast?
Nick Capodice: [00:31:49] I plead the fifth. [00:31:50] Hannah. Speaking of which, we should do an episode on that.
Hannah McCarthy: [00:31:52] How about doing an episode on what the people want?
Nick Capodice: [00:31:54] They might want.
Hannah McCarthy: [00:31:55] That. You don't know until you ask, do you?
Nick Capodice: [00:31:57] So do you guys want an episode on what [00:32:00] Pleading the fifth means?
Hannah McCarthy: [00:32:01] And while we're at it, what is something in your neighborhood that makes absolutely no sense to you? Or something that really helped a problem in your town, your [00:32:10] school district, on your highways with your trash pickup. Submit a question at our website by clicking the ask Civics 101 [00:32:20] button right underneath the latest episode on the home page. Or you can email us Civics 101 at npr.org. And if you have listened [00:32:30] long enough to hear me say this, I hope that means we are on the right track to journalism at its best, serving you, serving democracy. This [00:32:40] episode was produced by me, Hannah McCarthy with Nick Capodice. Taylor Quimby is our executive producer. Music in this episode comes from Epidemic Sound. We [00:32:50] have got lots and lots of episodes at our website, civics101podcast.org. And if we are to keep making more of them, we are definitely going to be looking to you. What ails you? [00:33:00] What brings you joy? What is working where you live? What is broken? Start with a small question and we will do our best to give you a bigger answer. [00:33:10] Civics 101 is a production of NHPR New Hampshire Public Radio.

